Left Heading Image Charleston County
Circuit Court Case Details
Public Index 		Right Heading Image
Mahmoud Shalaby , plaintiff, et al VS ACS Primary Care Physicians Southeast PC , defendant, et al
Case Number: 2019CP1000508 Court Agency: Common Pleas Filed Date: 02/01/2019
Case Type: Common Pleas Case Sub Type: Medical Malpract 220 File Type: Jury
Status: Disposed Assigned Judge: Clerk Of Court C P, G S, And Family Court
Disposition: Ended by Jury Trial Disposition Date: 07/31/2023 Disposition Judge: McCoy, Jennifer B.
Original Source Doc: Original Case #:
Judgment Number: Court Roster:

Case Parties
Click the icon to show associated parties.
NameAddressRaceSexYear Of BirthParty TypeParty StatusLast Updated
ACS Primary Care Physicians Southeast PC(Inactive) Defendant06/15/2023
Alexander, J. Ben(Inactive) One North Main Street PO Box 2048 Greenville SC 29602Defendant Attorney06/15/2023
Batten, David H. 4141 Parklake Avenue Ste. 350 Raleigh NC 27612Defendant Attorney04/14/2025
DeLuca, Christy Marie(Inactive) 2061 Willbrook Lane Mount Pleasant SC 29466Mediator08/29/2019
Dr Christiane McNeal MD Defendant03/04/2019
Gammons, Debra J.(Inactive) PO Box 535 Charleston SC 29402Alternate Mediator08/29/2019
Kunz, Andrew William PO Box 1405 Georgetown SC 29442Plaintiff Attorney06/12/2023
Lee, Randolph L. 219 Ridge Street Georgetown SC 29440Defendant Attorney11/13/2023
Mason, Elizabeth Ballentine 205 King Street Suite 201 Charleston SC 29401Defendant Attorney06/13/2022
McNeal, Christiane Dr Defendant03/04/2019
McNeal, Christiane MD Defendant11/19/2021
Shalaby, Ahmed Plaintiff02/04/2019
Shalaby, Mahmoud Plaintiff07/31/2023
Shalaby, Ahmed Estate of Plaintiff02/04/2019
Shalaby, Mahmoud as Personal Representative Plaintiff02/04/2019
Simmons, Chilton Grace 205 King Street Suite 201 Charleston SC 29401Defendant Attorney04/14/2025
Slocum, Lauren Knight Lauren Knight Slocum 119 Screven Street Georgetown SC 29440Plaintiff Attorney04/14/2025
Trident Medical Center(Inactive) Defendant06/25/2020
Associated Cases
AgencyCase #ExternalRelationshipDescriptionCase Filed DateDisposition DateCase StatusDisposition
Common Pleas2018CP1002621NCONSMahmoud Shalaby VS Trident Medical Center05/23/201802/28/2019ConsolidatedDismissed by Court - not Rule 40J
Common Pleas2018NI1000085NNOTMMMahmoud Shalaby VS ACS Primary Care Physicians Southeast PC10/24/2018Pending
Actions
NameDescriptionTypeMotion RosterBegin DateCompletion DateDocuments
Shalaby, MahmoudOrder Evidence Destruction - contact clerk within 30 daysOrder04/14/2025-15:30CMS Image Available Icon
Shalaby, MahmoudNEF(07-31-2023 04:40:49 PM) Order/Electronic Form 4Filing07/31/2023-16:41CMS Image Available Icon
Shalaby, MahmoudOrder/Form 4-jury verdict in favor of the defendantOrder07/31/2023-16:40CMS Image Available Icon
Shalaby, MahmoudNEF(06-16-2023 03:32:44 PM) Motion/In LimineFiling06/16/2023-15:4307/31/2023-15:43CMS Image Available Icon
Shalaby, MahmoudMotion/In LimineMotion06/16/2023-15:3207/31/2023-15:32CMS Image Available Icon
Shalaby, MahmoudNEF(06-15-2023 02:44:31 PM) Stipulation Of DismissalFiling06/15/2023-14:5107/31/2023-14:51CMS Image Available Icon
Shalaby, MahmoudStipulation Of Dismissal w/Prejudice, as to Certain PartiesFiling06/15/2023-14:4407/31/2023-14:44CMS Image Available Icon
Shalaby, MahmoudNEF(06-12-2023 09:45:34 AM) Notice/Notice of AppearanceFiling06/12/2023-09:4607/31/2023-09:46CMS Image Available Icon
Shalaby, MahmoudNotice/Notice of AppearanceFiling06/12/2023-09:4507/31/2023-09:45CMS Image Available Icon
Slocum, Lauren Knight6/20/2023_JRY_Roster/Notice of Case Roster Publication SentAction06/06/2023-11:5807/31/2023-11:58CMS Image Available Icon
Alexander, J. Ben6/20/2023_JRY_Roster/Notice of Case Roster Publication SentAction06/06/2023-11:5807/31/2023-11:58CMS Image Available Icon
Lee, Randolph L.6/20/2023_JRY_Roster/Notice of Case Roster Publication SentAction06/06/2023-11:5807/31/2023-11:58CMS Image Available Icon
Batten, David H.6/20/2023_JRY_Roster/Notice of Case Roster Publication SentAction06/06/2023-11:5807/31/2023-11:58CMS Image Available Icon
Mason, Elizabeth Ballentine6/20/2023_JRY_Roster/Notice of Case Roster Publication SentAction06/06/2023-11:5807/31/2023-11:58CMS Image Available Icon
Simmons, Chilton Grace6/20/2023_JRY_Roster/Notice of Case Roster Publication SentAction06/06/2023-11:5807/31/2023-11:58CMS Image Available Icon
Simmons, Chilton Grace6/20/2023_JRY_Roster/Notice of Case Roster Publication SentAction05/10/2023-16:3307/31/2023-16:33CMS Image Available Icon
Mason, Elizabeth Ballentine6/20/2023_JRY_Roster/Notice of Case Roster Publication SentAction05/10/2023-16:3307/31/2023-16:33CMS Image Available Icon
Lee, Randolph L.6/20/2023_JRY_Roster/Notice of Case Roster Publication SentAction05/10/2023-16:3307/31/2023-16:33CMS Image Available Icon
Batten, David H.6/20/2023_JRY_Roster/Notice of Case Roster Publication SentAction05/10/2023-16:3307/31/2023-16:33CMS Image Available Icon
Alexander, J. Ben6/20/2023_JRY_Roster/Notice of Case Roster Publication SentAction05/10/2023-16:3307/31/2023-16:33CMS Image Available Icon
Slocum, Lauren Knight6/20/2023_JRY_Roster/Notice of Case Roster Publication SentAction05/10/2023-16:3307/31/2023-16:33CMS Image Available Icon
Shalaby, MahmoudNEF(11-29-2022 10:11:16 AM) Order/Electronic Form 4Filing11/29/2022-10:1707/31/2023-10:17CMS Image Available Icon
Shalaby, MahmoudOrder/Case is Set for a Date Certain TrialOrder11/29/2022-10:1107/31/2023-10:11CMS Image Available Icon
ACS Primary Care Physicians Southeast PCNEF(05-24-2022 11:19:49 AM) Order/Protection from Court ...Filing05/24/2022-11:3207/31/2023-11:32CMS Image Available Icon
ACS Primary Care Physicians Southeast PCOrder/Protection from Court AppearanceOrder05/24/2022-11:1907/31/2023-11:19CMS Image Available Icon
ACS Primary Care Physicians Southeast PCNEF(05-16-2022 10:25:38 AM) Proposed Order/Protection fr...Filing05/16/2022-10:3007/31/2023-10:30CMS Image Available Icon
ACS Primary Care Physicians Southeast PCOrder/Order Cover Sheet $25.00Filing05/16/2022-10:2507/31/2023-10:25CMS Image Available Icon
McNeal, Christiane MDNEF(11-19-2021 03:44:34 PM) Order/Scheduling OrderFiling11/19/2021-15:4407/31/2023-15:44CMS Image Available Icon
McNeal, Christiane MDOrder/Scheduling OrderOrder11/19/2021-15:4407/31/2023-15:44CMS Image Available Icon
McNeal, Christiane MDNEF(11-19-2021 01:45:34 PM) Order/Order Cover Sheet $25....Filing11/19/2021-14:1607/31/2023-14:16CMS Image Available Icon
McNeal, Christiane MDOrder/Order Cover Sheet $25.00Filing11/19/2021-13:4507/31/2023-13:45CMS Image Available Icon
McNeal, Christiane MDNEF(11-08-2021 04:59:24 PM) Notice/Notice of AppearanceFiling11/08/2021-16:5907/31/2023-16:59CMS Image Available Icon
McNeal, Christiane MDNotice/Notice of AppearanceFiling11/08/2021-16:5907/31/2023-16:59CMS Image Available Icon
Lee, Randolph L.11/29/2021_JRY_Roster/Notice of Case Roster Publication SentAction11/08/2021-14:1107/31/2023-14:11CMS Image Available Icon
Batten, David H.11/29/2021_JRY_Roster/Notice of Case Roster Publication SentAction11/08/2021-14:1107/31/2023-14:11CMS Image Available Icon
Alexander, J. Ben11/29/2021_JRY_Roster/Notice of Case Roster Publication SentAction11/08/2021-14:1107/31/2023-14:11CMS Image Available Icon
Slocum, Lauren Knight11/29/2021_JRY_Roster/Notice of Case Roster Publication SentAction11/08/2021-14:1107/31/2023-14:11CMS Image Available Icon
Shalaby, MahmoudNEF(08-03-2021 02:17:27 PM) Order/OtherFiling08/03/2021-14:2507/31/2023-14:25CMS Image Available Icon
Shalaby, MahmoudOrder Granting Request to be Removed Fr/Date Certain TrialOrder08/03/2021-14:1707/31/2023-14:17CMS Image Available Icon
ACS Primary Care Physicians Southeast PCNEF(04-12-2021 03:04:51 PM) Order/Protection from Court ...Filing04/12/2021-15:0407/31/2023-15:04CMS Image Available Icon
ACS Primary Care Physicians Southeast PCOrder/Protection from Court AppearanceOrder04/12/2021-15:0407/31/2023-15:04CMS Image Available Icon
ACS Primary Care Physicians Southeast PCNEF(04-07-2021 11:40:18 AM) Proposed Order/Protection fr...Filing04/07/2021-11:4307/31/2023-11:43CMS Image Available Icon
ACS Primary Care Physicians Southeast PCOrder/Order Cover Sheet $25.00Filing04/07/2021-11:4007/31/2023-11:40CMS Image Available Icon
Shalaby, Ahmed Estate ofNEF(07-07-2020 11:30:53 AM) Stipulation Of DismissalFiling07/08/2020-09:5307/31/2023-09:53CMS Image Available Icon
Shalaby, Ahmed Estate ofStipulation Of Dismissal as to Trident Medical Center onlyFiling07/07/2020-11:3007/31/2023-11:30CMS Image Available Icon
Trident Medical CenterNEF(06-25-2020 12:53:59 PM) Order/Approval Of SettlementFiling06/25/2020-12:5407/31/2023-12:54CMS Image Available Icon
Trident Medical CenterOrder/Approval Of Settlement as to Trident MedicalOrder06/25/2020-12:5307/31/2023-12:53CMS Image Available Icon
Trident Medical CenterNEF(06-22-2020 03:50:16 PM) Proposed Order/Approval Of S...Filing06/22/2020-16:0707/31/2023-16:07CMS Image Available Icon
Trident Medical CenterOrder/Order Cover Sheet $25.00Filing06/22/2020-15:5007/31/2023-15:50CMS Image Available Icon
Shalaby, MahmoudNEF(06-02-2020 01:55:21 PM) ADR/Proof of ADRFiling06/02/2020-13:5507/31/2023-13:55CMS Image Available Icon
Shalaby, MahmoudProof of ADR At an ImpasseAction06/02/2020-13:5507/31/2023-13:55CMS Image Available Icon
Trident Medical CenterNEF(04-29-2020 12:58:57 PM) Petition/No Filing FeeFiling05/01/2020-09:4307/31/2023-09:43CMS Image Available Icon
Trident Medical CenterPetition for Approval of SettlementFiling04/29/2020-12:5807/31/2023-12:58CMS Image Available Icon
Trident Medical CenterNEF(04-29-2020 12:55:56 PM) Notice/Notice of AppearanceFiling04/29/2020-12:5607/31/2023-12:56CMS Image Available Icon
Trident Medical CenterNotice/Notice of AppearanceFiling04/29/2020-12:5507/31/2023-12:55CMS Image Available Icon
Shalaby, MahmoudNEF(02-07-2020 02:29:54 PM) Motion/Date CertainFiling02/07/2020-14:5507/31/2023-14:55CMS Image Available Icon
Shalaby, MahmoudMotion/Date CertainMotion02/07/2020-14:2903/19/2020-14:29CMS Image Available Icon
Shalaby, MahmoudADR/Notice of ADRAction11/27/2019-09:0206/02/2020-09:02
Shalaby, MahmoudADR/Alternative Dispute Resolution (Workflow)Action08/30/2019-13:3511/27/2019-13:35
Shalaby, MahmoudArchived DocumentFiling08/29/2019-00:0007/31/2023-00:00
Slocum, Lauren KnightArchived DocumentFiling08/29/2019-00:0007/31/2023-00:00
Alexander, J. BenArchived DocumentFiling08/29/2019-00:0007/31/2023-00:00
DeLuca, Christy MarieArchived DocumentFiling08/29/2019-00:0007/31/2023-00:00
Gammons, Debra J.Archived DocumentFiling08/29/2019-00:0007/31/2023-00:00
Consent Confidentiality OrderOrder06/03/2019-16:1307/31/2023-16:13CMS Image Available Icon
ACS Primary Care Physicians Southeast PCOrder/Order Filing FeeFiling05/09/2019-11:2907/31/2023-11:29
Consent Scheduling OrderOrder04/04/2019-09:1807/31/2023-09:18CMS Image Available Icon
Order to Consolidate/Merge 2018-CP-10-2621 Under This CaseOrder03/04/2019-11:0907/31/2023-11:09CMS Image Available Icon
ACS Primary Care Physicians Southeast PCAnswer, crt/srvFiling02/22/2019-09:2707/31/2023-09:27CMS Image Available Icon
Shalaby, MahmoudSummons & ComplaintFiling02/01/2019-13:3407/31/2023-13:34CMS Image Available Icon
Financials
Summary
Fine/Costs:$325.00Total Paid for fine/costs:$325.00Balance Due:$0.00

Costs
DescriptionCost CodeAmountCharge ActionDisbursed Amount
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
SCJD Filing Fee Proviso $50 / $25SCJDPV$50.00$50.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Civil Filing Fee State 56%CVFFST$56.00$56.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Civil Filing Fee County 44%/100%CVFFCN$44.00$44.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00

Payments
Payment DateReceipt NumberEntered ByTransaction Type CodePayment Amount
06/16/2023666562COCMRRPY$25.00
05/16/2022649149COCMRRWV$25.00
11/19/2021641344COCMRRPY$25.00
04/07/2021631751COCMRRWV$25.00
06/22/2020620222COCMRRPY$25.00
02/07/2020614809COCDTSPY$25.00
05/09/2019602742COCREEPY$25.00
02/01/2019598621COCSRJPY$150.00