Left Heading Image Charleston County
Circuit Court Case Details
Public Index 		Right Heading Image
Richard A Feigenbaum , plaintiff, et al VS Patrick Cogan , defendant, et al
Case Number: 2019CP1002356 Court Agency: Common Pleas Filed Date: 05/07/2019
Case Type: Common Pleas Case Sub Type: Slander/Libel 380 File Type: Jury
Status: Pending/ADR Sanctions Assigned Judge: Clerk Of Court C P, G S, And Family Court
Disposition: Disposition Date: Disposition Judge:
Original Source Doc: Original Case #:
Judgment Number: Court Roster:

Case Parties
Click the icon to show associated parties.
NameAddressRaceSexYear Of BirthParty TypeParty StatusLast Updated
Airbnb Inc(Inactive) Defendant12/09/2019
Cogan, Patrick Defendant04/09/2021
Duffy, Brian C 96 Broad Street Charleston SC 29401Plaintiff Attorney05/07/2019
Feigenbaum, Alexandra M Plaintiff05/08/2019
Feigenbaum, Michael P Plaintiff05/08/2019
Feigenbaum, Richard A Plaintiff09/11/2020
Fraser, Charles Elliott 11605 N. Community House Road Suite 150 Charlotte NC 28277Defendant Attorney07/08/2019
Haller, David K. 604 Savannah Highway Charleston SC 29407Defendant Attorney06/12/2019
Lagrand, Kimberly Defendant05/08/2019
Massalon, John A.(Inactive) PO Box 859 Charleston SC 29402Mediator12/03/2019
McKie, Blake Abernethy 96 Broad St. Charleston SC 29401Plaintiff Attorney07/05/2019
Story, Matthew Joseph(Inactive) 126 Seven Farms Drive Suite 200 Charleston SC 29492Alternate Mediator12/03/2019
Uddo, Eleanor M Plaintiff05/08/2019
Watson, Lewis Andrew 11605 North Community House Road Suite 150 Charlotte NC 28277Defendant Attorney07/08/2019
Actions
NameDescriptionTypeMotion RosterBegin DateCompletion DateDocuments
Cogan, PatrickNEF(04-09-2021 09:26:12 AM) Motion/CompelFiling04/09/2021-09:40CMS Image Available Icon
Cogan, PatrickMotion/Compel DiscoveryMotion04/09/2021-09:26CMS Image Available Icon
Duffy, Brian C2/15/2021_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction01/15/2021-14:13CMS Image Available Icon
Haller, David K.2/15/2021_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction01/15/2021-14:13CMS Image Available Icon
McKie, Blake Abernethy2/15/2021_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction01/15/2021-14:13CMS Image Available Icon
Watson, Lewis Andrew2/15/2021_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction01/15/2021-14:13CMS Image Available Icon
Fraser, Charles Elliott2/15/2021_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction01/15/2021-14:13CMS Image Available Icon
Fraser, Charles Elliott12/14/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction11/23/2020-17:17CMS Image Available Icon
Watson, Lewis Andrew12/14/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction11/23/2020-17:17CMS Image Available Icon
McKie, Blake Abernethy12/14/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction11/23/2020-17:17CMS Image Available Icon
Haller, David K.12/14/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction11/23/2020-17:17CMS Image Available Icon
Duffy, Brian C12/14/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction11/23/2020-17:17CMS Image Available Icon
Haller, David K.12/14/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction11/23/2020-17:17CMS Image Available Icon
McKie, Blake Abernethy12/14/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction11/23/2020-17:17CMS Image Available Icon
Watson, Lewis Andrew12/14/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction11/23/2020-17:17CMS Image Available Icon
Fraser, Charles Elliott12/14/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction11/23/2020-17:17CMS Image Available Icon
Duffy, Brian C12/14/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction11/23/2020-17:17CMS Image Available Icon
Duffy, Brian C12/14/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction11/13/2020-11:29CMS Image Available Icon
Duffy, Brian C12/14/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction11/13/2020-11:29CMS Image Available Icon
Fraser, Charles Elliott12/14/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction11/13/2020-11:29CMS Image Available Icon
Fraser, Charles Elliott12/14/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction11/13/2020-11:29CMS Image Available Icon
Watson, Lewis Andrew12/14/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction11/13/2020-11:29CMS Image Available Icon
Watson, Lewis Andrew12/14/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction11/13/2020-11:29CMS Image Available Icon
McKie, Blake Abernethy12/14/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction11/13/2020-11:29CMS Image Available Icon
McKie, Blake Abernethy12/14/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction11/13/2020-11:29CMS Image Available Icon
Haller, David K.12/14/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction11/13/2020-11:29CMS Image Available Icon
Haller, David K.12/14/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction11/13/2020-11:29CMS Image Available Icon
Haller, David K.10/12/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction09/14/2020-14:24CMS Image Available Icon
Haller, David K.10/12/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction09/14/2020-14:24CMS Image Available Icon
McKie, Blake Abernethy10/12/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction09/14/2020-14:24CMS Image Available Icon
McKie, Blake Abernethy10/12/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction09/14/2020-14:24CMS Image Available Icon
Watson, Lewis Andrew10/12/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction09/14/2020-14:24CMS Image Available Icon
Watson, Lewis Andrew10/12/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction09/14/2020-14:24CMS Image Available Icon
Fraser, Charles Elliott10/12/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction09/14/2020-14:24CMS Image Available Icon
Fraser, Charles Elliott10/12/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction09/14/2020-14:24CMS Image Available Icon
Duffy, Brian C10/12/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction09/14/2020-14:24CMS Image Available Icon
Duffy, Brian C10/12/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction09/14/2020-14:24CMS Image Available Icon
Feigenbaum, Richard ANEF(09-10-2020 04:23:40 PM) Motion/CompelFiling09/11/2020-08:48CMS Image Available Icon
Feigenbaum, Richard AMotion/Compel Response to DiscoveryMotion09/10/2020-16:2302/08/2021-16:23CMS Image Available Icon
Cogan, PatrickNEF(08-16-2020 04:59:03 PM) Motion/CompelFiling08/17/2020-10:32CMS Image Available Icon
Cogan, PatrickSecond Motion/Compel DiscoveryMotion08/16/2020-16:5912/11/2020-16:59CMS Image Available Icon
Feigenbaum, Richard ANEF(06-03-2020 03:29:34 PM) Order/Electronic Form 4Filing06/03/2020-15:29CMS Image Available Icon
Feigenbaum, Richard AOrder/Defnts Motion to Compel is GrantedOrder06/03/2020-15:29CMS Image Available Icon
Cogan, PatrickNEF(06-02-2020 12:45:09 PM) Filing/OtherFiling06/02/2020-14:24CMS Image Available Icon
Cogan, PatrickFiling/Exhibits to Motion to CompelFiling06/02/2020-12:45CMS Image Available Icon
Duffy, Brian C5/29/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction05/28/2020-15:13
Fraser, Charles Elliott5/29/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction05/28/2020-15:13
Watson, Lewis Andrew5/29/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction05/28/2020-15:13
McKie, Blake Abernethy5/29/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction05/28/2020-15:13
Haller, David K.5/29/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction05/28/2020-15:13
Feigenbaum, Richard ANEF(05-26-2020 02:51:56 PM) Memo/Memo in OppositionFiling05/26/2020-16:29CMS Image Available Icon
Feigenbaum, Richard APltffs Memo in Opposition To Crt/Defnts Motion to CompelFiling05/26/2020-14:51CMS Image Available Icon
Duffy, Brian C6/1/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction05/26/2020-08:48
Haller, David K.6/1/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction05/26/2020-08:48
McKie, Blake Abernethy6/1/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction05/26/2020-08:48
Watson, Lewis Andrew6/1/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction05/26/2020-08:48
Fraser, Charles Elliott6/1/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction05/26/2020-08:48
Fraser, Charles Elliott5/29/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction05/19/2020-11:25
Watson, Lewis Andrew5/29/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction05/19/2020-11:25
McKie, Blake Abernethy5/29/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction05/19/2020-11:25
Haller, David K.5/29/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction05/19/2020-11:25
Duffy, Brian C5/29/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction05/19/2020-11:25
Feigenbaum, Richard ANEF(03-30-2020 01:27:50 PM) Answer/Amended Answer And Co...Filing03/31/2020-08:36CMS Image Available Icon
Feigenbaum, Richard A2nd Amended Answer And CounterclaimFiling03/30/2020-13:27CMS Image Available Icon
Cogan, PatrickNEF(03-23-2020 11:24:44 AM) Motion/CompelFiling03/23/2020-14:49CMS Image Available Icon
Cogan, PatrickMotion/CompelMotion03/23/2020-11:2406/03/2020-11:24CMS Image Available Icon
Cogan, PatrickNEF(03-20-2020 12:42:41 PM) Answer/Amended Answer And Co...Filing03/20/2020-14:38CMS Image Available Icon
Cogan, Patrick2nd Amended Answer to Complaint And CounterclaimFiling03/20/2020-12:42CMS Image Available Icon
Feigenbaum, Richard ANEF(03-16-2020 04:11:09 PM) Answer/Amended AnswerFiling03/16/2020-16:32CMS Image Available Icon
Feigenbaum, Richard AAnswer to Amended Answer & C/claim of Crtn DefntsFiling03/16/2020-16:11CMS Image Available Icon
Feigenbaum, Richard ANEF(03-13-2020 03:21:31 PM) Order/AmendFiling03/13/2020-15:21CMS Image Available Icon
Feigenbaum, Richard AConsent Order Granting Leave to Amend AnswerOrder03/13/2020-15:21CMS Image Available Icon
Feigenbaum, Richard ANEF(03-11-2020 02:00:35 PM) Proposed Order/AmendFiling03/11/2020-14:17CMS Image Available Icon
Feigenbaum, Richard AOrder/Order Cover Sheet $25.00Filing03/11/2020-14:00
Feigenbaum, Richard ANEF(03-11-2020 11:48:08 AM) Motion/Alter and/or AmendFiling03/11/2020-13:38CMS Image Available Icon
Feigenbaum, Richard AConsent Motion Granting Leave to Amend Plntffs' AnswerMotion03/11/2020-11:4805/26/2020-11:48CMS Image Available Icon
Feigenbaum, Richard AADR/Notice of ADRAction03/02/2020-09:31CMS Image Available Icon
Duffy, Brian C3/27/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction02/24/2020-09:48
Haller, David K.3/27/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction02/24/2020-09:48
McKie, Blake Abernethy3/27/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction02/24/2020-09:48
Watson, Lewis Andrew3/27/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction02/24/2020-09:48
Fraser, Charles Elliott3/27/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction02/24/2020-09:48
Feigenbaum, Richard ANEF(01-17-2020 04:15:28 PM) Order/Protection from Court ...Filing01/17/2020-16:15CMS Image Available Icon
Feigenbaum, Richard AOrder/Protection from Court AppearanceOrder01/17/2020-16:15CMS Image Available Icon
Feigenbaum, Richard ANEF(01-17-2020 12:26:58 PM) Order/Order Cover Sheet $25....Filing01/17/2020-13:34CMS Image Available Icon
Feigenbaum, Richard AOrder/Order Cover Sheet $25.00Filing01/17/2020-12:26
Feigenbaum, Richard ANEF(12-09-2019 10:07:24 AM) Stipulation Of DismissalFiling12/09/2019-10:26CMS Image Available Icon
Feigenbaum, Richard AStipulation Of Dismissal W/Out Prejudice as to AirbnbFiling12/09/2019-10:07CMS Image Available Icon
Feigenbaum, Richard AADR/Alternative Dispute Resolution (Workflow)Action12/03/2019-14:2403/02/2020-14:24
Feigenbaum, Richard ANEF(12-03-2019 09:31:55 AM) ADR/Notice of ADRFiling12/03/2019-09:31CMS Image Available Icon
Feigenbaum, Richard ANEF(11-14-2019 11:18:45 AM) Order/Consent OrderFiling11/14/2019-11:18CMS Image Available Icon
Feigenbaum, Richard AConsent Order on Motion to CompelOrder11/14/2019-11:18CMS Image Available Icon
Feigenbaum, Richard ANEF(11-13-2019 02:39:05 PM) Proposed Order/Consent OrderFiling11/13/2019-16:40CMS Image Available Icon
Feigenbaum, Richard AOrder/Order Cover Sheet $25.00Filing11/13/2019-14:39
Duffy, Brian C11/12/2019_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction10/14/2019-08:28
Fraser, Charles Elliott11/12/2019_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction10/14/2019-08:28
Watson, Lewis Andrew11/12/2019_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction10/14/2019-08:28
McKie, Blake Abernethy11/12/2019_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction10/14/2019-08:28
Haller, David K.11/12/2019_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction10/14/2019-08:28
Feigenbaum, Richard AMotion/Motion Filing FeeFiling09/30/2019-16:11
McKie, Blake AbernethyPltff Motion/Compel & Crt/SrvMotion09/30/2019-10:4302/24/2020-10:43CMS Image Available Icon
Consent Order on Preliminary InjunctionOrder08/29/2019-11:15CMS Image Available Icon
Plaintiffs' Answer to Amended Counterclaims, crt/srvFiling08/05/2019-14:00CMS Image Available Icon
Airbnb IncAnswer to Cr/Claim of Patrick Cogan & Kimberly Lagrand, srvFiling07/24/2019-13:57CMS Image Available Icon
Airbnb IncAnswer, crt/srvFiling07/24/2019-13:54CMS Image Available Icon
Filing/Declaration of Kyle Miller In Support of Defnt MotionFiling07/24/2019-12:15CMS Image Available Icon
Watson, Lewis AndrewDefnt Motion/Compel & Crt/SrvMotion07/24/2019-12:1411/13/2019-12:14CMS Image Available Icon
Filing/Declaration of Kyle Miller in Support of Defnt MotionFiling07/24/2019-12:12CMS Image Available Icon
Watson, Lewis AndrewDefnt Motion/Compel & Crt/SrvMotion07/24/2019-12:0911/13/2019-12:09CMS Image Available Icon
Airbnb IncMotion/Motion Filing FeeFiling07/24/2019-10:28
Airbnb IncMotion/Motion Filing FeeFiling07/24/2019-10:25
Amended Answer of Certain Defendants, Counterclaim, crt/srvFiling07/23/2019-11:21CMS Image Available Icon
Airbnb IncNotice of Appearance of Atty Watson & Atty Fraser, crt/srvFiling07/03/2019-16:27CMS Image Available Icon
Plaintiffs' Answer to Counterclaims, crt/srvFiling07/01/2019-14:04CMS Image Available Icon
Answer & Counterclaim of Certain Defnts & crt/srvFiling06/11/2019-08:58CMS Image Available Icon
Service/Proof OfFiling05/20/2019-12:20CMS Image Available Icon
Affidavit Of Service (2)Filing05/13/2019-16:42CMS Image Available Icon
Feigenbaum, Richard AMotion/Motion Filing FeeFiling05/07/2019-14:27
Feigenbaum, Richard ASummons & ComplaintFiling05/07/2019-14:21CMS Image Available Icon
Duffy, Brian CPlaintiffs Motion for Preliminary Injunction & crt/srvMotion05/07/2019-14:1308/27/2019-14:13CMS Image Available Icon
Affidavit of Eleanor M UddoFiling05/07/2019-14:08CMS Image Available Icon
Affidavit of Richard A FeigenbaumFiling05/07/2019-14:07CMS Image Available Icon
Financials
Summary
Fine/Costs:$450.00Total Paid for fine/costs:$450.00Balance Due:$0.00

Costs
DescriptionCost CodeAmountCharge ActionDisbursed Amount
Civil Filing Fee County 44%/100%CVFFCN$44.00$44.00
Civil Filing Fee State 56%CVFFST$56.00$56.00
SCJD Filing Fee Proviso $50 / $25SCJDPV$50.00$50.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00

Payments
Payment DateReceipt NumberEntered ByTransaction Type CodePayment Amount
04/09/2021631839COCDTSPY$25.00
09/11/2020623581COCDTSPY$25.00
08/17/2020622580COCDTSPY$25.00
03/23/2020617182COCDTSPY$25.00
03/11/2020616599COCMRRPY$25.00
03/11/2020616611COCMRRWV$25.00
01/17/2020613577COCMRRWV$25.00
11/13/2019610663COCMRRWV$25.00
09/30/2019608499cocmrrPY$25.00
07/24/2019605846COCAXBPY$25.00
07/24/2019605847COCAXBPY$25.00
05/07/2019602654COCMRRPY$150.00
05/07/2019602655COCMRRPY$25.00
Case PartiesJudgmentsTax Map InformationAssociated CasesActionsFinancials
Click the icon to show associated parties.
NameAddressRaceSexYear Of BirthParty TypeParty StatusLast Updated
Airbnb Inc(Inactive) Defendant12/09/2019
Cogan, Patrick Defendant04/09/2021
Duffy, Brian C 96 Broad Street Charleston SC 29401Plaintiff Attorney05/07/2019
Feigenbaum, Alexandra M Plaintiff05/08/2019
Feigenbaum, Michael P Plaintiff05/08/2019
Feigenbaum, Richard A Plaintiff09/11/2020
Fraser, Charles Elliott 11605 N. Community House Road Suite 150 Charlotte NC 28277Defendant Attorney07/08/2019
Haller, David K. 604 Savannah Highway Charleston SC 29407Defendant Attorney06/12/2019
Lagrand, Kimberly Defendant05/08/2019
Massalon, John A.(Inactive) PO Box 859 Charleston SC 29402Mediator12/03/2019
McKie, Blake Abernethy 96 Broad St. Charleston SC 29401Plaintiff Attorney07/05/2019
Story, Matthew Joseph(Inactive) 126 Seven Farms Drive Suite 200 Charleston SC 29492Alternate Mediator12/03/2019
Uddo, Eleanor M Plaintiff05/08/2019
Watson, Lewis Andrew 11605 North Community House Road Suite 150 Charlotte NC 28277Defendant Attorney07/08/2019