Left Heading Image Charleston County
Circuit Court Case Details
Public Index 		Right Heading Image
Donna Friedman , plaintiff, et al VS Alan Nussbaum MD , defendant, et al
Case Number: 2018CP1000222 Court Agency: Common Pleas Filed Date: 01/18/2018
Case Type: Common Pleas Case Sub Type: Medical Malpract 220 File Type: Jury
Status: Settled Assigned Judge: Clerk Of Court C P, G S, And Family Court
Disposition: Withdrawn or Settled by Parties Disposition Date: 01/21/2025 Disposition Judge: Clerk Of Court C P, G S, And Family Court
Original Source Doc: Original Case #:
Judgment Number: Court Roster:

Case Parties
Click the icon to show associated parties.
NameAddressRaceSexYear Of BirthParty TypeParty StatusLast Updated
Adams, Ryan Timothy(Inactive) 497 St. Andrews Boulevard Charleston SC 29407Defendant Attorney06/05/2023
Barnes, A. Parker Jr.(Inactive) PO Drawer 1729 Beaufort SC 299011729Alternate Mediator08/17/2018
Bradshaw, Julia A.(Inactive) Copeland, Stair, Valz & Lovell, LLP 40 Calhoun Street, Suite 400 Charleston SC 29401Defendant Attorney06/05/2023
Chambers, Robert Gerald Jr.(Inactive) PO Box 1473 Columbia SC 29202Defendant Attorney09/08/2021
Friedman, Donna Plaintiff01/27/2025
Friedman, Randy Plaintiff01/19/2018
Hood, Robert H. 172 Meeting Street Charleston SC 29401Defendant Attorney02/27/2018
Hood, Robert Holmes Jr. PO Box 1508 Charleston SC 294021508Defendant Attorney01/27/2020
Horton, Kevin Richard 100 Calhoun Street Suite 400 Charleston SC 29402Attorney11/06/2024
Jones, Timothy M.D Other Party to Case05/04/2022
Marini, Chase Langston 205 King Street, Suite 201 Charleston SC 29401Defendant Attorney11/06/2024
Morgan, Hunter Adam 40 Calhoun Street Suite 200 Charleston SC 29401Defendant Attorney10/11/2024
Murphy, Edward T DMD Defendant11/27/2024
Nussbaum, Alan MD Defendant11/27/2024
Periodontal Associates PA Defendant01/19/2018
Ransom, Robert B. Leventis & Ransom PO Box 11067 Columbia SC 29211Plaintiff Attorney01/19/2024
Rheumatology Associates PA Defendant01/19/2018
Smyth, Todd W. 115 Central Island Street Suite 250 Charleston SC 29492Attorney10/11/2024
Smythe, Susan Mackall(Inactive) PO Box 999 Charleston SC 29402Mediator06/05/2023
Tierney, Joseph John Jr. 205 King Street Suite 201 Charleston SC 29401Defendant Attorney04/26/2022
Williamson, Maryrose Pritchard 172 Meeting Street Charleston SC 29401Defendant Attorney07/08/2022
Associated Cases
AgencyCase #ExternalRelationshipDescriptionCase Filed DateDisposition DateCase StatusDisposition
Common Pleas2016NI1000070NNOTMMDonna Friedman VS Alan Nussbaum Md11/28/201612/15/2017EndedEnded by Judgment/Dismissal-Arbit/Mediat
Actions
NameDescriptionTypeMotion RosterBegin DateCompletion DateDocuments
Nussbaum, Alan MDNEF(01-24-2025 02:26:52 PM) Stipulation Of DismissalFiling01/27/2025-14:36CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDNEF(01-21-2025 02:08:46 PM) Stipulation Of DismissalFiling01/27/2025-08:36CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDStipulation Of Dismissal W/PrejudiceFiling01/24/2025-14:26CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDStipulation Of Dismissal W/PrejudiceFiling01/21/2025-14:08CMS Image Available Icon
Friedman, DonnaNEF(11-27-2024 04:04:20 PM) Motion/In LimineFiling11/27/2024-16:1301/21/2025-16:13CMS Image Available Icon
Friedman, DonnaNEF(11-27-2024 04:07:17 PM) Memo/Memo in OppositionFiling11/27/2024-16:1201/21/2025-16:12CMS Image Available Icon
Friedman, DonnaPlaintiff Response to Motion to Compel and for ContinuanceFiling11/27/2024-16:0701/21/2025-16:07CMS Image Available Icon
Friedman, DonnaMotion/In LimineMotion11/27/2024-16:0412/02/2024-16:04CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDNEF(11-27-2024 02:56:53 PM) Motion/In LimineFiling11/27/2024-15:1101/21/2025-15:11CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDMotion/In Limine Preclude Dr Nussbaum Fr/TestifyingMotion11/27/2024-14:5612/02/2024-14:56CMS Image Available Icon
Murphy, Edward T DMDNEF(11-27-2024 02:09:29 PM) Motion/In LimineFiling11/27/2024-14:3001/21/2025-14:30CMS Image Available Icon
Murphy, Edward T DMDMotion/In Limine to Exclude Any Expert Opinion TestimonyMotion11/27/2024-14:0912/02/2024-14:09CMS Image Available Icon
Murphy, Edward T DMDNEF(11-27-2024 01:39:19 PM) Motion/In LimineFiling11/27/2024-13:5201/21/2025-13:52CMS Image Available Icon
Murphy, Edward T DMDMotion/In Limine to Exclude Plntffs' Summaries Any RecordsMotion11/27/2024-13:3911/27/2024-13:39CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDNEF(11-27-2024 12:25:52 PM) Motion/In LimineFiling11/27/2024-13:2801/21/2025-13:28CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDNEF(11-27-2024 12:33:26 PM) Motion/ExcludeFiling11/27/2024-13:2701/21/2025-13:27CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDNEF(11-27-2024 12:14:37 PM) Motion/In LimineFiling11/27/2024-13:2601/21/2025-13:26CMS Image Available Icon
Rheumatology Associates PANEF(11-27-2024 12:02:03 PM) Motion/ExcludeFiling11/27/2024-13:1701/21/2025-13:17CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDMotion/In Limine Exclude Any New &/or Undisclosed ExpertMotion11/27/2024-12:3312/02/2024-12:33CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDMotion/In Limine Exclude Medical Records at Trial PlaintiffsMotion11/27/2024-12:2512/02/2024-12:25CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDMotion/In Limine to Preclude Hearsay StatementsMotion11/27/2024-12:1412/02/2024-12:14CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDNEF(11-27-2024 11:51:15 AM) Motion/ExcludeFiling11/27/2024-12:0401/21/2025-12:04CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDMotion/In Limine Exclude Any Reference to SettlementMotion11/27/2024-12:0212/02/2024-12:02CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDMotion in Limine to Exclude Reptile Litigation TacticsMotion11/27/2024-11:5112/02/2024-11:51CMS Image Available Icon
Murphy, Edward T DMDNEF(11-25-2024 02:02:41 PM) Motion/ContinuanceFiling11/25/2024-15:3201/21/2025-15:32CMS Image Available Icon
Murphy, Edward T DMDMotion/Continuance & Certificate of MailingMotion11/25/2024-14:0211/25/2024-14:02CMS Image Available Icon
Murphy, Edward T DMDNEF(11-22-2024 05:37:44 PM) Motion/CompelFiling11/25/2024-09:5401/21/2025-09:54CMS Image Available Icon
Murphy, Edward T DMDMotion/Compel or Exclude Evidence & Certificate of MailingMotion11/22/2024-17:3711/22/2024-17:37CMS Image Available Icon
Hood, Robert H.12/2/2024_JRY_Roster/Notice of Case Roster Publication SentAction11/06/2024-15:4501/21/2025-15:45CMS Image Available Icon
Hood, Robert Holmes Jr.12/2/2024_JRY_Roster/Notice of Case Roster Publication SentAction11/06/2024-15:4501/21/2025-15:45CMS Image Available Icon
Smyth, Todd W.12/2/2024_JRY_Roster/Notice of Case Roster Publication SentAction11/06/2024-15:4501/21/2025-15:45CMS Image Available Icon
Horton, Kevin Richard12/2/2024_JRY_Roster/Notice of Case Roster Publication SentAction11/06/2024-15:4501/21/2025-15:45CMS Image Available Icon
Williamson, Maryrose Pritchard12/2/2024_JRY_Roster/Notice of Case Roster Publication SentAction11/06/2024-15:4501/21/2025-15:45CMS Image Available Icon
Morgan, Hunter Adam12/2/2024_JRY_Roster/Notice of Case Roster Publication SentAction11/06/2024-15:4501/21/2025-15:45CMS Image Available Icon
Tierney, Joseph John Jr.12/2/2024_JRY_Roster/Notice of Case Roster Publication SentAction11/06/2024-15:4501/21/2025-15:45CMS Image Available Icon
Marini, Chase Langston12/2/2024_JRY_Roster/Notice of Case Roster Publication SentAction11/06/2024-15:4501/21/2025-15:45CMS Image Available Icon
Ransom, Robert B.12/2/2024_JRY_Roster/Notice of Case Roster Publication SentAction11/06/2024-15:4501/21/2025-15:45CMS Image Available Icon
Ransom, Robert B.11/8/2024_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction10/11/2024-08:4201/21/2025-08:42CMS Image Available Icon
Tierney, Joseph John Jr.11/8/2024_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction10/11/2024-08:4201/21/2025-08:42CMS Image Available Icon
Marini, Chase Langston11/8/2024_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction10/11/2024-08:4201/21/2025-08:42CMS Image Available Icon
Williamson, Maryrose Pritchard11/8/2024_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction10/11/2024-08:4201/21/2025-08:42CMS Image Available Icon
Morgan, Hunter Adam11/8/2024_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction10/11/2024-08:4201/21/2025-08:42CMS Image Available Icon
Horton, Kevin Richard11/8/2024_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction10/11/2024-08:4201/21/2025-08:42CMS Image Available Icon
Smyth, Todd W.11/8/2024_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction10/11/2024-08:4201/21/2025-08:42CMS Image Available Icon
Hood, Robert Holmes Jr.11/8/2024_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction10/11/2024-08:4201/21/2025-08:42CMS Image Available Icon
Hood, Robert H.11/8/2024_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction10/11/2024-08:4201/21/2025-08:42CMS Image Available Icon
Friedman, DonnaNEF(09-13-2024 10:15:55 AM) Motion/OtherFiling09/13/2024-10:4201/21/2025-10:42CMS Image Available Icon
Friedman, DonnaMotion/Hearing on Objections During De Benne Esse VideoMotion09/13/2024-10:1511/08/2024-10:15CMS Image Available Icon
Friedman, DonnaNEF(05-13-2024 10:01:29 AM) Order/Electronic Form 4Filing05/13/2024-10:0101/21/2025-10:01CMS Image Available Icon
Friedman, DonnaOrder/Case is Set for a Date Certain TrialOrder05/13/2024-10:0101/21/2025-10:01CMS Image Available Icon
Murphy, Edward T DMDNEF(02-02-2024 11:13:01 AM) Answer/Answer To Amended Com...Filing02/02/2024-11:3801/21/2025-11:38CMS Image Available Icon
Murphy, Edward T DMDNEF(02-02-2024 11:17:37 AM) Notice/Notice of AppearanceFiling02/02/2024-11:1701/21/2025-11:17CMS Image Available Icon
Murphy, Edward T DMDNotice/Notice of AppearanceFiling02/02/2024-11:1701/21/2025-11:17CMS Image Available Icon
Murphy, Edward T DMDAnswer To Amended ComplaintFiling02/02/2024-11:1301/21/2025-11:13CMS Image Available Icon
Rheumatology Associates PANEF(02-01-2024 01:27:30 PM) Answer/Answer To Amended Com...Filing02/01/2024-13:5601/21/2025-13:56CMS Image Available Icon
Rheumatology Associates PAAnswer To Amended Complaint, Jury Trial RequestedFiling02/01/2024-13:2701/21/2025-13:27CMS Image Available Icon
Friedman, DonnaNEF(01-24-2024 09:38:45 AM) Amended/Amended Summons And ...Filing01/24/2024-11:3201/21/2025-11:32CMS Image Available Icon
Friedman, DonnaAmended ComplaintFiling01/24/2024-09:3801/21/2025-09:38CMS Image Available Icon
Friedman, DonnaNEF(01-19-2024 11:08:25 AM) Order/AmendFiling01/19/2024-11:0801/21/2025-11:08CMS Image Available Icon
Friedman, DonnaConsent Order Granting Leave to Amend ComplaintOrder01/19/2024-11:0801/21/2025-11:08CMS Image Available Icon
Friedman, DonnaNEF(01-17-2024 12:41:30 PM) Order/Order Cover Sheet $25....Filing01/17/2024-14:2001/21/2025-14:20CMS Image Available Icon
Friedman, DonnaOrder/Order Cover Sheet $25.00Filing01/17/2024-12:4101/21/2025-12:41CMS Image Available Icon
Friedman, DonnaNEF(01-12-2024 07:37:49 AM) Motion/Alter and/or AmendFiling01/12/2024-08:5401/21/2025-08:54CMS Image Available Icon
Friedman, DonnaMotion/Leave to File & Serve Amended ComplaintMotion01/12/2024-07:3701/19/2024-07:37CMS Image Available Icon
Friedman, DonnaFiling: Amended ComplaintFiling01/12/2024-07:3701/21/2025-07:37CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDNEF(06-05-2023 11:27:10 AM) Notice/OtherFiling06/05/2023-11:3201/21/2025-11:32CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDNotice of Withdrawal of CounselFiling06/05/2023-11:2701/21/2025-11:27CMS Image Available Icon
Friedman, DonnaNEF(04-10-2023 11:06:56 AM) ADR/Proof of ADRFiling04/10/2023-11:0701/21/2025-11:07CMS Image Available Icon
Friedman, DonnaADR/Proof of ADR ImpasseAction04/10/2023-11:0601/21/2025-11:06CMS Image Available Icon
Friedman, DonnaNEF(01-11-2023 09:36:00 AM) Order/Electronic Form 4Filing01/11/2023-09:3701/21/2025-09:37CMS Image Available Icon
Friedman, DonnaOrder/Trial Not Before DateOrder01/11/2023-09:3601/21/2025-09:36CMS Image Available Icon
Friedman, DonnaNEF(12-09-2022 11:52:54 AM) Request/RequestFiling12/09/2022-12:5601/21/2025-12:56CMS Image Available Icon
Friedman, DonnaRequest for Status ConferenceFiling12/09/2022-11:5201/21/2025-11:52CMS Image Available Icon
Friedman, DonnaNEF(11-15-2022 11:41:57 AM) Order/Electronic Form 4Filing11/15/2022-11:4301/21/2025-11:43CMS Image Available Icon
Friedman, DonnaOrder/Date Certain TrialOrder11/15/2022-11:4101/21/2025-11:41CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDNEF(08-08-2022 03:02:05 PM) Order/AmendFiling08/08/2022-15:0501/21/2025-15:05CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDOrder/Motion to Alter/Amend Judgment of Crtn Parties GrantedOrder08/08/2022-15:0201/21/2025-15:02CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDNEF(08-04-2022 12:04:38 PM) Proposed Order/AmendFiling08/04/2022-13:3101/21/2025-13:31CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDOrder/Order Cover Sheet $25.00Filing08/04/2022-12:0401/21/2025-12:04CMS Image Available Icon
Ransom, Robert B.8/1/2022_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction07/08/2022-12:3601/21/2025-12:36CMS Image Available Icon
Ransom, Robert B.8/1/2022_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction07/08/2022-12:3601/21/2025-12:36CMS Image Available Icon
Hood, Robert H.8/1/2022_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction07/08/2022-12:3601/21/2025-12:36CMS Image Available Icon
Hood, Robert H.8/1/2022_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction07/08/2022-12:3601/21/2025-12:36CMS Image Available Icon
Adams, Ryan Timothy8/1/2022_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction07/08/2022-12:3601/21/2025-12:36CMS Image Available Icon
Adams, Ryan Timothy8/1/2022_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction07/08/2022-12:3601/21/2025-12:36CMS Image Available Icon
Bradshaw, Julia A.8/1/2022_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction07/08/2022-12:3601/21/2025-12:36CMS Image Available Icon
Bradshaw, Julia A.8/1/2022_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction07/08/2022-12:3601/21/2025-12:36CMS Image Available Icon
Hood, Robert Holmes Jr.8/1/2022_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction07/08/2022-12:3601/21/2025-12:36CMS Image Available Icon
Hood, Robert Holmes Jr.8/1/2022_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction07/08/2022-12:3601/21/2025-12:36CMS Image Available Icon
Smyth, Todd W.8/1/2022_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction07/08/2022-12:3601/21/2025-12:36CMS Image Available Icon
Smyth, Todd W.8/1/2022_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction07/08/2022-12:3601/21/2025-12:36CMS Image Available Icon
Horton, Kevin Richard8/1/2022_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction07/08/2022-12:3601/21/2025-12:36CMS Image Available Icon
Horton, Kevin Richard8/1/2022_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction07/08/2022-12:3601/21/2025-12:36CMS Image Available Icon
Williamson, Maryrose Pritchard8/1/2022_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction07/08/2022-12:3601/21/2025-12:36CMS Image Available Icon
Williamson, Maryrose Pritchard8/1/2022_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction07/08/2022-12:3601/21/2025-12:36CMS Image Available Icon
Morgan, Hunter Adam8/1/2022_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction07/08/2022-12:3601/21/2025-12:36CMS Image Available Icon
Morgan, Hunter Adam8/1/2022_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction07/08/2022-12:3601/21/2025-12:36CMS Image Available Icon
Tierney, Joseph John Jr.8/1/2022_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction07/08/2022-12:3601/21/2025-12:36CMS Image Available Icon
Tierney, Joseph John Jr.8/1/2022_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction07/08/2022-12:3601/21/2025-12:36CMS Image Available Icon
Jones, Timothy M.DNEF(05-04-2022 03:01:49 PM) Motion/Alter and/or AmendFiling05/04/2022-15:1701/21/2025-15:17CMS Image Available Icon
Jones, Timothy M.DMotion/Alter or Amend JudgmentMotion05/04/2022-15:0108/03/2022-15:01CMS Image Available Icon
Friedman, DonnaNEF(04-15-2022 09:32:10 PM) Memo/Memo in OppositionFiling04/18/2022-08:0501/21/2025-08:05CMS Image Available Icon
Friedman, DonnaOpposition To Dr Nussbaums Rule 59 Motion To Alter Or AmendFiling04/15/2022-21:3201/21/2025-21:32CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDNEF(04-11-2022 04:15:28 PM) Motion/Alter and/or AmendFiling04/12/2022-06:5801/21/2025-06:58CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDMotion/Alter and/or Amend Order Granting Motion/QuashMotion04/11/2022-16:1508/03/2022-16:15CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDNEF(02-09-2022 03:15:53 PM) Order/QuashFiling02/09/2022-15:1601/21/2025-15:16CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDOrder Granting Motion to QuashOrder02/09/2022-15:1501/21/2025-15:15CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDNEF(02-04-2022 03:30:53 PM) Proposed Order/QuashFiling02/04/2022-16:0701/21/2025-16:07CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDOrder/Order Cover Sheet $25.00Filing02/04/2022-15:3001/21/2025-15:30CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDNEF(01-28-2022 04:21:09 PM) Order/Electronic Form 4Filing01/28/2022-16:2101/21/2025-16:21CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDOrder/Motion to Quash Pltff Subpoena to Non Party is GrantedOrder01/28/2022-16:2101/21/2025-16:21CMS Image Available Icon
Friedman, DonnaNEF(11-19-2021 03:47:09 PM) Memo/Memo in OppositionFiling11/19/2021-15:5801/21/2025-15:58CMS Image Available Icon
Friedman, DonnaResponse to Motion for Protective Order & Motion to QuashFiling11/19/2021-15:4701/21/2025-15:47CMS Image Available Icon
Ransom, Robert B.11/29/2021_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction11/02/2021-15:2801/21/2025-15:28CMS Image Available Icon
Williamson, Maryrose Pritchard11/29/2021_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction11/02/2021-15:2801/21/2025-15:28CMS Image Available Icon
Morgan, Hunter Adam11/29/2021_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction11/02/2021-15:2801/21/2025-15:28CMS Image Available Icon
Tierney, Joseph John Jr.11/29/2021_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction11/02/2021-15:2801/21/2025-15:28CMS Image Available Icon
Horton, Kevin Richard11/29/2021_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction11/02/2021-15:2801/21/2025-15:28CMS Image Available Icon
Smyth, Todd W.11/29/2021_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction11/02/2021-15:2801/21/2025-15:28CMS Image Available Icon
Bradshaw, Julia A.11/29/2021_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction11/02/2021-15:2801/21/2025-15:28CMS Image Available Icon
Hood, Robert Holmes Jr.11/29/2021_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction11/02/2021-15:2801/21/2025-15:28CMS Image Available Icon
Adams, Ryan Timothy11/29/2021_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction11/02/2021-15:2801/21/2025-15:28CMS Image Available Icon
Hood, Robert H.11/29/2021_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction11/02/2021-15:2801/21/2025-15:28CMS Image Available Icon
Murphy, Edward T DMDNEF(09-08-2021 09:41:09 AM) Order/Substitution Of Counse...Filing09/08/2021-09:4101/21/2025-09:41CMS Image Available Icon
Murphy, Edward T DMDOrder/Substitution Of Counsel for DefendantOrder09/08/2021-09:4101/21/2025-09:41CMS Image Available Icon
Murphy, Edward T DMDNEF(09-07-2021 12:50:24 PM) Notice/Notice of AppearanceFiling09/07/2021-13:2501/21/2025-13:25CMS Image Available Icon
Murphy, Edward T DMDNotice/Notice of AppearanceFiling09/07/2021-12:5001/21/2025-12:50CMS Image Available Icon
Murphy, Edward T DMDOrder/Order Cover Sheet $25.00Filing09/07/2021-12:5001/21/2025-12:50CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDNEF(08-03-2021 12:06:34 PM) Motion/QuashFiling08/03/2021-13:1701/21/2025-13:17CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDMotion/Quash Plntff's Subpoena to Non-Party Timothy Jones MDMotion08/03/2021-12:0611/30/2021-12:06CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDNEF(06-29-2021 03:02:04 PM) Order/Scheduling OrderFiling06/29/2021-15:0201/21/2025-15:02CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDOrder/Scheduling OrderOrder06/29/2021-15:0201/21/2025-15:02CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDNEF(06-28-2021 06:52:48 PM) Proposed Order/Scheduling Or...Filing06/29/2021-07:1301/21/2025-07:13CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDOrder/Order Cover Sheet $25.00Filing06/28/2021-18:5201/21/2025-18:52CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDNEF(05-24-2021 08:21:52 PM) Order/Protection from Court ...Filing05/24/2021-20:2201/21/2025-20:22CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDOrder/Protection from Court AppearanceOrder05/24/2021-20:2101/21/2025-20:21CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDNEF(05-20-2021 07:34:12 PM) Proposed Order/Protection fr...Filing05/21/2021-07:3001/21/2025-07:30CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDNotice/Notice of AppearanceFiling05/20/2021-19:3401/21/2025-19:34CMS Image Available Icon
Jones, Timothy M.DNEF(05-17-2021 04:12:06 PM) Add Party to CaseFiling05/18/2021-06:2801/21/2025-06:28CMS Image Available Icon
Jones, Timothy M.DAdd Party to CaseFiling05/17/2021-16:1201/21/2025-16:12CMS Image Available Icon
Jones, Timothy M.DMotion F/Protective OrderMotion05/17/2021-16:1205/24/2021-16:12CMS Image Available Icon
Friedman, DonnaNEF(05-26-2020 02:59:52 PM) Motion/Date CertainFiling05/26/2020-15:0901/21/2025-15:09CMS Image Available Icon
Friedman, DonnaMotion/Date Certain TrialMotion05/26/2020-14:5906/29/2020-14:59CMS Image Available Icon
Ransom, Robert B.5/29/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction05/19/2020-11:2501/21/2025-11:25
Bradshaw, Julia A.5/29/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction05/19/2020-11:2501/21/2025-11:25
Hood, Robert H.5/29/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction05/19/2020-11:2501/21/2025-11:25
Adams, Ryan Timothy5/29/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction05/19/2020-11:2501/21/2025-11:25
Chambers, Robert Gerald Jr.5/29/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction05/19/2020-11:2501/21/2025-11:25
Hood, Robert Holmes Jr.5/29/2020_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction05/19/2020-11:2501/21/2025-11:25
Murphy, Edward T DMDNEF(03-09-2020 08:50:10 AM) Order/Protection from Court ...Filing03/09/2020-08:5001/21/2025-08:50CMS Image Available Icon
Murphy, Edward T DMDOrder/Protection from Court AppearanceOrder03/09/2020-08:5001/21/2025-08:50CMS Image Available Icon
Murphy, Edward T DMDNEF(03-06-2020 12:55:02 PM) Order/Order Cover Sheet $25....Filing03/06/2020-16:2701/21/2025-16:27CMS Image Available Icon
Murphy, Edward T DMDOrder/Order Cover Sheet $25.00Filing03/06/2020-12:5501/21/2025-12:55
Friedman, DonnaNEF(03-04-2020 07:03:00 AM) Motion/CompelFiling03/04/2020-09:4401/21/2025-09:44CMS Image Available Icon
Friedman, DonnaMotion/Compel disclosure of expertsMotion03/04/2020-07:0305/21/2020-07:03CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDNEF(02-21-2020 12:30:43 PM) Answer/Amended AnswerFiling02/24/2020-10:0301/21/2025-10:03CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDAmended Answer of Alan Nussbaum & Rheumotology Assoc, JTDFiling02/21/2020-12:3001/21/2025-12:30CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDNotice of Appearance of Atty BradshawFiling02/21/2020-12:3001/21/2025-12:30CMS Image Available Icon
Murphy, Edward T DMDNEF(02-12-2020 03:01:35 PM) Answer/Amended AnswerFiling02/12/2020-15:0401/21/2025-15:04CMS Image Available Icon
Murphy, Edward T DMDCertain Defendants Amended AnswerFiling02/12/2020-15:0101/21/2025-15:01CMS Image Available Icon
Rheumatology Associates PANEF(02-10-2020 04:34:06 PM) Order/AmendFiling02/10/2020-16:3401/21/2025-16:34CMS Image Available Icon
Rheumatology Associates PAConsent Order to Amend Defnts AnswerOrder02/10/2020-16:3401/21/2025-16:34CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDNEF(02-10-2020 11:36:52 AM) Proposed Order/AmendFiling02/10/2020-11:5901/21/2025-11:59CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDOrder/Order Cover Sheet $25.00Filing02/10/2020-11:3601/21/2025-11:36
Ransom, Robert B.2/3/2020_JRY_Roster/Notice of Case Roster Publication SentAction01/28/2020-08:4801/21/2025-08:48
Hood, Robert Holmes Jr.2/3/2020_JRY_Roster/Notice of Case Roster Publication SentAction01/28/2020-08:4801/21/2025-08:48
Adams, Ryan Timothy2/3/2020_JRY_Roster/Notice of Case Roster Publication SentAction01/28/2020-08:4801/21/2025-08:48
Chambers, Robert Gerald Jr.2/3/2020_JRY_Roster/Notice of Case Roster Publication SentAction01/28/2020-08:4801/21/2025-08:48
Hood, Robert H.2/3/2020_JRY_Roster/Notice of Case Roster Publication SentAction01/28/2020-08:4801/21/2025-08:48
Nussbaum, Alan MDNEF(01-27-2020 03:17:06 PM) Notice/Notice of AppearanceFiling01/27/2020-15:1701/21/2025-15:17CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDNotice/Notice of AppearanceFiling01/27/2020-15:1701/21/2025-15:17
Nussbaum, Alan MDNEF(01-27-2020 12:55:13 PM) Order/Scheduling OrderFiling01/27/2020-12:5501/21/2025-12:55CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDOrder/Scheduling OrderOrder01/27/2020-12:5501/21/2025-12:55CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDNEF(01-27-2020 10:55:02 AM) Order/Order Cover Sheet $25....Filing01/27/2020-11:3401/21/2025-11:34CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDOrder/Order Cover Sheet $25.00Filing01/27/2020-10:5501/21/2025-10:55
Nussbaum, Alan MDNotice/Notice of AppearanceFiling01/27/2020-10:5501/21/2025-10:55
Second Consent Scheduling OrderOrder06/26/2019-14:2301/21/2025-14:23CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDOrder/Order Filing FeeFiling06/21/2019-12:5001/21/2025-12:50
Order-Pltffs Motion to Compel is DeniedOrder12/28/2018-09:5601/21/2025-09:56CMS Image Available Icon
Consent Scheduling OrderOrder12/05/2018-10:2601/21/2025-10:26CMS Image Available Icon
Nussbaum, Alan MDOrder/Order Filing FeeFiling11/29/2018-15:1801/21/2025-15:18
Pltffs' Memo on Motion for In Camera Review, crt/mailingFiling11/20/2018-09:2601/21/2025-09:26CMS Image Available Icon
Friedman, DonnaADR/Notice of ADRAction11/15/2018-08:1604/10/2023-08:16
Ransom, Robert B.11/26/2018_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction11/05/2018-08:4101/21/2025-08:41
Hood, Robert H.11/26/2018_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction11/05/2018-08:4101/21/2025-08:41
Chambers, Robert Gerald Jr.11/26/2018_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction11/05/2018-08:4101/21/2025-08:41
Chambers, Robert Gerald Jr.11/29/2018_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction11/01/2018-09:4501/21/2025-09:45
Hood, Robert H.11/29/2018_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction11/01/2018-09:4501/21/2025-09:45
Ransom, Robert B.11/29/2018_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicatioAction11/01/2018-09:4501/21/2025-09:45
Friedman, DonnaMotion/Motion Filing FeeFiling10/22/2018-12:2701/21/2025-12:27
Ransom, Robert B.Pltff Motion/Compel & Crt/MailingMotion10/22/2018-10:2711/27/2018-10:27CMS Image Available Icon
Friedman, DonnaArchived DocumentFiling08/17/2018-00:0001/21/2025-00:00
Friedman, DonnaADR/Alternative Dispute Resolution (Workflow)Action08/16/2018-11:0311/15/2018-11:03
Ransom, Robert B.7/9/2018_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction06/13/2018-08:2901/21/2025-08:29
Hood, Robert H.7/9/2018_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction06/13/2018-08:2901/21/2025-08:29
Chambers, Robert Gerald Jr.7/9/2018_MOTION_Roster/Notice of Motions Roster PublicationAction06/13/2018-08:2901/21/2025-08:29
Ransom, Robert B.Motion/Compel by Plaintiff, crt/mailingMotion04/27/2018-11:5807/09/2018-11:58CMS Image Available Icon
Friedman, DonnaMotion/Motion Filing FeeFiling04/27/2018-11:0101/21/2025-11:01
E Murphy MD & Periodontal Assoc Ans to Cmplnt & c/servFiling02/26/2018-09:0501/21/2025-09:05CMS Image Available Icon
Certain Defnts Answer, Jury Trial Requested & cert/srvFiling02/22/2018-11:5101/21/2025-11:51CMS Image Available Icon
Friedman, DonnaSummons & ComplaintFiling01/18/2018-11:0101/21/2025-11:01CMS Image Available Icon
Financials
Summary
Fine/Costs:$925.00Total Paid for fine/costs:$925.00Balance Due:$0.00

Costs
DescriptionCost CodeAmountCharge ActionDisbursed Amount
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
SCJD Filing Fee Proviso $50 / $25SCJDPV$50.00$50.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Civil Filing Fee State 56%CVFFST$56.00$56.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Civil Filing Fee County 44%/100%CVFFCN$44.00$44.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00
Motion/Order Filing Fee $25MOTION$25.00$25.00

Payments
Payment DateReceipt NumberEntered ByTransaction Type CodePayment Amount
11/27/2024691415COCMRRPY$25.00
11/27/2024691420COCMRRPY$25.00
11/27/2024691422COCMRRPY$25.00
11/27/2024691423COCMRRPY$25.00
11/27/2024691424COCMRRPY$25.00
11/27/2024691426COCMRRPY$25.00
11/27/2024691430COCMRRPY$25.00
11/27/2024691436COCMRRPY$25.00
11/27/2024691440COCMRRPY$25.00
11/25/2024691245COCMRRPY$25.00
11/25/2024691279COCMRRPY$25.00
09/13/2024687622COCMRRPY$25.00
01/17/2024676090COCWLLPY$25.00
01/12/2024675891COCMRRPY$25.00
08/04/2022652519COCALBPY$25.00
05/04/2022648649COCMRRPY$25.00
04/12/2022647605COCMRRPY$25.00
02/04/2022644345COCMRRPY$25.00
09/07/2021638261COCMRRWV$25.00
08/03/2021636816COCMRRPY$25.00
06/29/2021635249COCMRRPY$25.00
05/18/2021633463COCMRRPY$25.00
05/26/2020619034COCDTSPY$25.00
03/06/2020616391COCMRRWV$25.00
03/04/2020616155COCDTSPY$25.00
02/10/2020614854COCMRRPY$25.00
01/27/2020614075COCMRRPY$25.00
06/21/2019604614COCAXBPY$25.00
11/29/2018596261COCJSJPY$25.00
10/22/2018594870COCMRRPY$25.00
04/27/2018588050COCKDGPY$25.00
01/18/2018583707COCMRRPY$150.00